Comment on:
The following comment refers to this/these guideline(s)
Guideline 15
Publication medium
Authors select the publication medium carefully, with due regard for its quality and visibility in the relevant field of discourse. Researchers who assume the role of editor carefully select where they will carry out this activity. The scientific/academic quality of a contribution does not depend on the medium in which it is published.
Explanations:
In addition to publication in books and journals, authors may also consider academic repositories, data and software repositories, and blogs. A new or unknown publication medium is evaluated to assess its seriousness.
A key criterion to selecting a publication medium is whether it has established guidelines on good research practice.
Minimum standards of quality assurance for research publications
The following checking procedures and quality assurance measures must be ensured by the publishers or the persons responsible at the publication venue:
Steps 1 to 3 must be ensured prior to initial publication, while step 4 can take place after publication.
For each publication, it must be clear which stage it is at (i.e. version, indication of status with reference to the review process or type of review process, link to other publications of similar content or underlying research data, date of initial publication, etc.).
Meanwhile, a publication venue must fulfil the minimum criteria for guaranteeing aspects 1 to 3 in terms of quality assurance as listed above so that the publications issued there can be cited in proposals, for example. In addition, it is imperative that the publication venue shows all processes associated with the publication in a transparent and correct manner. The Directory of Open Access Journals (DOAJ) contains the “Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing” – a list of a journal’s criteria that are to be disclosed according to best practice.
The comment belongs to the following categories:
GL15 (General)
Keywords:
publicationquality assurance